Religious sisters lead first class-action suit against HHS mandate
Sept. 25, 2013
The Little Sisters of the Poor have filed the first class-action lawsuit against the federal contraception mandate, saying that it would require them to violate the teachings of their Catholic faith. “Like all of the Little Sisters, I have vowed to God and the Roman Catholic Church that I will treat all life as valuable, and I have dedicated my life to that work,” Mother Loraine Marie Clare Maguire, superior of the congregation’s Baltimore province, said Sept. 24. “We cannot violate our vows by participating in the government’s program to provide access to abortion inducing drugs.” The Little Sisters of the Poor Home for the Aged in Denver and the Little Sisters of the Poor Baltimore, Inc., both non-profit corporations, are plaintiffs in the suit, as well as “all others similarly situated.”
The sisters, who operate 30 homes for needy elderly persons in the U.S., could face millions of dollars in IRS fines if they do not comply with government mandates requiring employee health coverage for sterilization and contraception, including some drugs that can cause early abortions. Employers that fail to provide the required coverage face fines of $100 per employee per day. The sisters’ lawsuit is the latest of more than 70 legal challenges that have been filed against the mandate on behalf of more than 200 plaintiffs nationwide. The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty filed the class-action suit in federal District Court in Denver on behalf of the sisters and their health benefits provider, Christian Brothers Services and Christian Brothers Employee Benefits Trust.
The legal group said the IRS fines begin Jan. 1 unless the sisters hire an outside company to provide the objectionable coverage. While the mandate has an exemption for religious employers, the Little Sisters of the Poor do not meet the narrow criteria to qualify for it because although they are a Catholic institution, they are not affiliated with a specific house of worship.“The Sisters should obviously be exempted as ‘religious employers,’ but the government has refused to expand its definition,” said Mark Rienzi, Senior Counsel for the Becket Fund. “These women just want to take care of the elderly poor without being forced to violate the faith that animates their work. The money they collect should be used to care for the poor like it always has – and not to pay the IRS.”
The Becket Fund says this is the first class-action suit concerning the mandate and will represent hundreds of Catholic non-profit ministries with similar beliefs. The lawsuit is also the first to represent benefits providers who cannot comply with the mandate in good conscience. The lawsuit cites the anomaly of the government’s refusal to grant an exemption to Catholic groups, despite other non-religious exemptions granted to thousands of other plans affected by the 2010 health care legislation. Members of the affected class face a “stark choice” and “must either abandon their Catholic beliefs” or be “punished by the government with an array of fines and penalties unless and until they comply,” the suit contends. “The threat of such penalties imposes a substantial burden on the class members’ religious exercise,” it states, arguing that the mandate violates the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
Source: Catholic News Agency
Other international News
OSWALD CARDINAL GRACIAS, ARCHBISHOP OF BOMBAY APPOINTED TO ROMAN ROTA
“The Holy Father has granted the title of Lawyer of the Roman Rota to Cardinal Oswald Graci...
Feb. 21, 2017
New Apostolic Nuncio for India and Nepal
His Holiness Pope Francis has appointed His Excellency most reverend GIAMBATTISTA DIQUATTRO as th...
Jan. 22, 2017
All invited for Cardinal Fernandez’s celebration
A thanksgiving Mass, to celebrate the elevation of His Eminence Cardinal Anthony Soter Fernandez,...
Dec. 20, 2016
THE ELEVENTH PLENARY ASSEMBLY OF THE FEDERATION OF ASIAN BISHOPS’ CONFERENCE
Taize prayer nourished Asian Bishops’ meetAn ecumenical form of worship, Taize has become a...
Dec. 5, 2016
Asian Bishops urged to aid families face modern threats
The assembly began with the bishops listening to Pope Francis’ special envoy urging them to...
Dec. 2, 2016